AITA for hitting my sister back when she attacked me, even though I ended up hurting her?

So, this happened recently, and I can’t stop thinking about it. I (22M) got into a physical altercation with my sister (24F), and now things are really tense in the family.

For context, I’m a lot smaller than my sister — she’s a few inches taller and has at least 40 pounds on me. Despite that, she’s always been really quick-tempered and aggressive when we argue.

We got into a heated argument over something dumb (as it always is), but this time, she snapped and physically attacked me. She shoved me first, then started swinging.

I backed off and told her to stop multiple times, but she wouldn’t. At one point she pushed me against the wall and kept hitting, and I just reacted — I swung back. I didn’t even think, it was instinct. My punch connected and I ended up giving her a bloody nose and a bruised cheek.

She stopped after that and started crying, and now my parents are furious at me for “taking it too far,” even though she started it and I was trying to protect myself. I didn’t want to hurt her — I was just trying to make her stop. I’m honestly feeling really messed up about it, even though I know I didn’t start the fight.

Now everyone’s acting like I’m the bad guy. I’m being told that hitting a woman — especially my sister — is “never okay,” regardless of the situation. But I honestly don’t know what else I could’ve done in that moment.

So… AITA for hitting my sister back when she attacked me first?

 

Related articles

Buy My Dream Home And Kept It In My Mom’s Safe For Few Days. But The Next Morning, I Woke Up To Find

Trust is often considered the bedrock of family. It’s the silent understanding that no matter the circumstances, your loved ones will protect you, support you, and never…

Called Me After: Oh, By The Way, The Party’s Just Immediate Family. Hope You Understand. $10,200

In families, generosity is often seen as love in action. For Brooke Harrison, a 28-year-old financial analyst in Boston, generosity wasn’t just a gesture—it was a lifelong…

They KICKED ME OUT of My Family Reunion Because I Didn’t Pay for Their Dinner | Reddit Family Drama

Family reunions are often envisioned as joyous celebrations—a time to reconnect, share memories, and reaffirm the bonds that unite us. For Weston Parker, a 32-year-old financial consultant…

My Step-Family Mocked My Finances On Christmas — Then My Private Jet Landed

In a world obsessed with surface-level wealth, flashy displays of status, and loud declarations of success, Natalie Carter’s New Year’s Eve reveals the ultimate lesson in understated…

“Get Out – Paying Bills Doesn’t Make You Family,” My Dad Snapped On Thanksgiving. Mom Whispered,

Rachel Morgan’s story is not simply one of financial burden—it is a deeply resonant narrative of emotional awakening, family dysfunction, and the quiet unraveling of a woman…

Family Said I Failed — Then Her CEO Looked Shocked And Said “You’re my biggest investor ”

In a society that often measures success by external accolades and visible milestones, Celia Grant’s story stands as a profound counter-narrative—a quiet, defiant anthem of resilience, reinvention,…